I’m just showing people a possible look for the reviews system on Gamed Up, although admittedly, I think I have an idea as to how I’ll be changing the images…

What's the score?
Presentation
How the game itself is presented, i.e. the story, plot, design, and the ideas the developer was trying to convey. Also covers how well everything is implemented.
Audio
Covers sound and music.
Visuals
How everything in the game looks.
Gameplay
How the game is to play, such as the controls and how everything interacts together, as well as how fun it is to actually play.
Value
Is the game worth buying at its current price? Also, will you be able to play the game again or is it basically going to be thrown away after completion?
Overall
This is the overall score of the game, which is NOT calculated by average

Here is a list of the descriptions of each score as well, to quantify the numbers in words:

0 – Non-existant (Features*) / Don’t bother (Overall)
1 – Terrible
2 – Awful
3 – Bad
4 – Below Average
5 – Average
6 – Above Average
7 – Good
8 – Very Good
9 – Excellent
10 – Outstanding (Features*) / Must-Buy (Overall)

* Features is defined as Presentation, Gameplay, Audio, Visuals and Value.